Why visual identity works best as the expression of decisions already made.
"We need a new logo" is one of the most common requests a designer hears. It is rarely the real problem.
I started my career making things look right. Over time I learned that a beautiful identity built on unclear foundations is just well-dressed confusion.
What a logo can't do
A logo can't decide who you are for. It can't make a vague offer clear. It can't fix a promise your operations don't keep. It can signal all of those things once they are true.
The order that works
- Identity: purpose, beliefs, personality — who we are when no one is watching.
- Positioning: for whom, against what alternative, and why us.
- Promise: what people can rely on, and the proof behind it.
- Expression: name, logo, colour, type, voice — the visible layer.
When expression comes last, design decisions become easier and more defensible. You're no longer choosing a colour you like; you're choosing the colour that says what you've already decided.
A useful brief
Before any visual work, try to answer in one line each: Who are we for? What do they get from us that they can't easily get elsewhere? How should they feel after dealing with us? If those answers are fuzzy, the logo will be too — no matter how good the designer is.
If your logo changed tomorrow, what about your business would still be recognisable?
Write back to me